This post is courtesy of Commit Swimming, the #1 workout journal for coaches and athletes, as well as Abbie Fish of RITTER Sports Performance, a stroke mechanics guru who believes anyone with the heart to train can benefit from technical advice!
Let’s get started!
Throughout swimming history, there has been a large debate on whether using your arms on the blocks while starting—actually improves your starts. Some coaches thought it was best to just throw your hands forward and get them into a streamline–as quick as possible. While others believed engaging your arms actually allows a swimmer to create more forward momentum with their body. Which belief is true?
The latter is. Why?
Photo Courtesy: Stephen Frink
The introduction of the back foot plate back in 2008.
Now, this may seem like a very interesting answer! As most coaches and swimmers believe the back foot plate allows a swimmer to generate more forward propulsion with their legs, rather than the arms. But in reality, the back foot plate affected a swimmer’s ability to generate more force with the arms—just as much as the legs. Let’s take a look and see.
This image was taken from the book, “The Science of Swimming Faster” by Scott Riewald and Scott Rodeo featured on the HumanKinetics website.
In this image, you can see they compared the force values generated from a “grab start”, versus, a “track start” using the back foot plate.
Keep in mind: All the forces generated are created by Newton’s third law of motion: for every action—there is an equal and opposite reaction.
1.) Grab Start: both of a swimmer’s feet are at the front of the block and all 10 toes curled over the edge.
Photo Courtesy: Stephen Frink
2.) Track Start: A swimmer’s legs are in a split-stance position with their dominant foots’ toes curled over the edge and their rear foot is placed behind them—on the back foot plate.
Photo Courtesy: Stephen Frink
What they found when comparing these two start’s vertical force was a swimmer generates relatively the same amount of vertical force at the beginning, but by the end of the start—a track start’s vertical force greatly depletes.
The reason there is a higher vertical force during a grab start is due to the fact that a swimmer lowers their body more towards the blocks during a grab start, than a track start. To achieve a good start, we aren’t solely concerned about vertical force. In reality, we want a swimmer to jump forward and not up—so how much force is generated in the vertical motion is not something we are super concerned about.
Let’s look at the more important horizontal force.
During a grab start, there is a slow development of horizontal force that results in a maximum peak value. During a track start, there are two smaller peaks and a horizontal higher force is generated more quickly. The reason there are two peaks during a track starts is due to legs and arm motions not happening all at the same time (in a track start).
The first peak in horizontal force is a result from aggressive arm motion, coupled with pushing off of the back foot plate with the rear foot. The second peak is a result from front foot push-off and a swimmer’s center of gravity shifting in front of the foot. Overall, the horizontal force created during a track start never peaks as high, as it does with a grab start. BUT, the average horizontal force produced over time is greater than grab starts!
So, what does this mean with using your arms during the dive?
Photo Courtesy: Stephen Frink
The more a swimmer can appropriately load their back leg AND engage their arm muscles, the quicker and more horizontal force they will be able to produce! This is why we’ve seen an increase in so-called “sling-shot” starts, which are a swimmer loading their back-leg prior to the start and using their arms to increase their forward momentum before their fingers hit the water. It is the sling-shot starts that generate the highest average horizontal force, which produces the highest starting velocity for a swimmer!
Be sure to tune in next week where we discuss what arm motions are available for a swimmer to use after they hear the “beep”, and what proper block positioning looks like.
Until Next Time,
A. Fish
Abbie Fish is now offering readers a FREE dolphin kick [stroke technique] lesson! Get access to about Abbie’s amazing lesson HERE.
Commit Swimming offers a 2-week free trial so you can see why all of the top coaches are using Commit to write, organize, and analyze workouts. But don’t take our word for it, here are what coaches have said about Commit:
“I’m excited to be coaching and using your software again, it really is as good as you advertise.”
“After using a different workout manager for 16 years, I was amazed how easy it was to switch to Commit.”
“Commit is one of the best things that has happened to my coaching.“
Track statrs have helped me even up my start .i tended to dive in nearly on my side..must habve had a weaker leg .
Niek Heethaar Sanne Ditzel